theres three of us here let's push realiti up to top wagon right now
-
Welcome to Smogon! Take a moment to read the Introduction to Smogon for a run-down on everything Smogon, and make sure you take some time to read the global rules.
NOC Smalltown Hotel Mafia - Game Thread (MAFIA WINS)
- Thread starter CaffeineBoost
- Start date
oh hi there hal
Ty
Without doing the work I wanted to I think I’m at
Don’t vote psy (not contentious)
I would prefer not to vote realiti or celever atm
I would put hal in this group based on thread reads atm but I think a ton of people are gonna ignore that
Everyone else im still sorting with Tommy being the biggest ping. Gth jalmont/ls(slight above null)> skipper/ag/oden/hydro (sort tier) > m2h > tommy
I've been waiting so long for someone to call him m2h
I'll wait
yes PLEASE ELI STOP DOING THAT!!!!!!!!!!!!
I guess third times the charm so we'll let you get pocketed by hal here and then hopefully next time you can properly solve him
Like the specific meta point about m24 is that last game he was flashbanging his reads early on and quickly committed to a vote
But here he has a late entrance, made a readslist, then voted on a developing wagon (tbh I thought it was more stark cos I thought there were more votes on hal) that did not align at all with his readslist. So that’s why I called it out because it felt distinct
And his response to me while like fine sure mindset think about what the other person is thinking and if it makes sense felt like he didn’t wanna be scumread for it. He even said he was gonna unvote but implied that being conditioned into it made it feel better
Also nai but it sounded like oden and m24 didn’t have the vc in front of them since they were going off my assumption on the wagon being larger than it was. So like wtf
So can I parse if that’s towny nervousness? Not atm, because all I have is my reads and my mobile phone
But here he has a late entrance, made a readslist, then voted on a developing wagon (tbh I thought it was more stark cos I thought there were more votes on hal) that did not align at all with his readslist. So that’s why I called it out because it felt distinct
And his response to me while like fine sure mindset think about what the other person is thinking and if it makes sense felt like he didn’t wanna be scumread for it. He even said he was gonna unvote but implied that being conditioned into it made it feel better
Also nai but it sounded like oden and m24 didn’t have the vc in front of them since they were going off my assumption on the wagon being larger than it was. So like wtf
So can I parse if that’s towny nervousness? Not atm, because all I have is my reads and my mobile phone
Also yeah like great hal decided to backtrack his wtf read on me because the main issue was that I townread you and then decided to sheep my reads and then ignored me
That’s awesome
To me it’s not an easily parsible behavior because it’s foreign to me, and I just came off a game where I just no brained a read on him, because after 10 games where we were t/t and
So if his scum meta is to adapt to his towngame
Like what’s his adaptation this game
Throwing out barf ass reads then immediately switching it up and agreeing with my (stated) reads in thread and continuing to push to same poe
TO ME it’s not that easily parsible given my history with him, or maybe I’m just bad at mafia and stuff
That’s awesome
To me it’s not an easily parsible behavior because it’s foreign to me, and I just came off a game where I just no brained a read on him, because after 10 games where we were t/t and
So if his scum meta is to adapt to his towngame
Like what’s his adaptation this game
Throwing out barf ass reads then immediately switching it up and agreeing with my (stated) reads in thread and continuing to push to same poe
TO ME it’s not that easily parsible given my history with him, or maybe I’m just bad at mafia and stuff
And no it doesnt stop the fact that Tommy’s iso lacks any sort of fire, even still
It doesn’t stop that he thinks hal is above rand town and isn’t cautioning the thread against a wagon against hal because of that
He’s voting fucking realiti because of a “lack of content”
Who has indicated their desire to push that wagon with him like nobody lol. Cos it’s not accomplishing him and he’s shrugged off any votes on him and has only been trying to appeal to psy specifically
Like am I being hypocritical cos im not really stating my reads either? Maybe but I do this anyway? Do I think it’s weird for Tommy specifically though? Yes, especially given his past game entrances! Am I reading into behavior that isn’t actually alignment indicative? Idk maybe
It doesn’t stop that he thinks hal is above rand town and isn’t cautioning the thread against a wagon against hal because of that
He’s voting fucking realiti because of a “lack of content”
Who has indicated their desire to push that wagon with him like nobody lol. Cos it’s not accomplishing him and he’s shrugged off any votes on him and has only been trying to appeal to psy specifically
Like am I being hypocritical cos im not really stating my reads either? Maybe but I do this anyway? Do I think it’s weird for Tommy specifically though? Yes, especially given his past game entrances! Am I reading into behavior that isn’t actually alignment indicative? Idk maybe
his adaption is to confuse you. which he is succeeding at
i never said to disregard reads...i'm not saying do things strictly my way, i just think we should consider the setup because we have that information. we're hamstringing ourselves by not doing so (or one is mafia hoping town does suboptimal things. a possibility.)
you should WANT to follow my strat as if we let mafia!doublevoter or poisoner advance in this game...with 2 MLs we LOSE the game if either of those roles are mafia. I'm trying to let your reads do the work late!
btw saying it now but hes probably getting left today, eli should be scrutinized as the game goes on. his post on the hal wagon was pretty awful and shut down-y
jalmont who are you voting for right now i forgot
Well I mean you hit the point it was intended to be shut downy
Sure, although entire thing was just behavior though
Nobody seems to be townreading hal
Like to you is it just that easy?
btw this read list makes me nervous. me, eli, celever are the people whove been the most welcoming towards you. please dont townread us based off of that. these are either scummy reads or youre at risk of being pocketed so id ask you to reconsider those slots please
sorry i just reread this and laughed again
............................?